Based on the 1959 book of the same name by robert a. Was verhoevens starship troopers intended to be a satire on. Later science fiction books such as joe haldemans antiwar novel the forever war have been described as reactions to starship troopers. The film has almost nothing whatsoever to do with the original book except minor superficial trappings.
Starship troopers is a trenchant, satirical commentary on fascism, the militaryindustrial complex, and our love of violence, masquerading as a dumb actioner, featuring pretty people spouting cheesy dialogue, amidst cgi carnage and bare boobs and butts. Heinlein, starship troopers is a science fiction film directed by famed science fiction director paul verhoeven. An interview with macaulay culkin about why hes such a big fan of paul verhoevens 1997 scifi satire film starship troopers. The book was a serious work with philosophical and political ideas packaged in a form palatable to young readers e. It wasnt meant to be based on heinleins classic work. Heinlein, starship troopers is a science fiction film. Nor do i think the movie has a single blessed thing to do with the book, somebody just liked the title evidently. This is satire in the same way repeating what someone says in an intentionally dumbsounding voice is an impersonation. And the satire was based on verhoevenmadeup strawman society which had virtually nothing in common with one in the book. Starship troopers also relies heavily on verhoevens collaboration with ed neumeier. It had the stated intention of treating its material in an ironic or sarcastic manner, to undermine the political ideology of the novel. No, starship troopers is not brilliant satire movie forums. Paul verhoevens manic, misunderstood satire michael moreci. Recalling his childhood in holland during the nazi occupation, verhoeven turns this epic adventure into a scathingly funny satire of fascist propaganda, emphasizing heinleins underlying warning against the hazards of military conformity.
He was a fourtime winner of the hugo award for his novels stranger in a strange land 1961, starship troopers 1959, double star 1956, and the moon is a harsh mistress 1966. The terms fascist and fascism get thrown around a lot, but rarely with accuracy. The book is not about war in the traditional sense, its about morality, the why we do things and the cost of doing them, both monetarily and spiritually. The story has been adapted several times, including in a 1997 film version directed by paul verhoeven that sought to satirize what the director saw as the fascist aspects of the novel. Starship troopers may be a satirical antifascist moviebut. Real, penetrating satire sneaks up on you and causes you consider things from a. Starship troopers takes place in the midst of an interstellar war between the terran federation of earth and the arachnids referred to as the bugs of klendathu. Macaulay culkin on the brilliant satire of starship troopers vulture.
This military scifi novel has all the aspects of hard science fiction i love. The fact that it was and continues to be taken at face value speaks to the very vapidity the movie skewers. It is narrated as a series of flashbacks by juan rico, and is one of just a few heinlein novels set out in this fashion. Furthermore, starship troopers didnt even originate as starship troopers. Jul 16, 2018 the terms fascist and fascism get thrown around a lot, but rarely with accuracy. Already the news that columbia pictures is planning a new movie adaptation of starship troopers, the scifi war story published by robert a. What is the minimal age, at which starship troopers the. The book that starship troopers is adapted from starship troopers by. Nov 16, 2016 one week after the election of donald trump, paul verhoeven was at the film society of lincoln center presenting starship troopers, a 1997 film that highlighted the fascist possibilities of. Hugh pickens dot com writes calum marsh writes in the atlantic that when paul verhoevens starship troopers hit theaters 16 years ago today, american critics slammed it as a crazed, lurid spectacle featuring raunchiness tailormade for teenage boys and a nonstop splatterfest so devoid of tast. This line from starship troopersuttered by an unnamed extra, strolling through the burning rubble of buenos aires in a military propaganda videocaptures the gonzo spirit of director paul verhoevens military satire, which turned 20 this week. And i think it is important to point out that federal service in the book was not strictly military. Starship troopers is one of my favorite films of all time. The director, paul verhoeven, definitely interpreted heinleins novel in this way.
Heinlein in 1959, has divided social media over whether. Starship troopers is a movie about war, yet verhoeven manages, with a deft hand, to display admiration for the military at times while eviscerating it at other times though, to be fair, the. Of course, given that, none of the book s many moralpolitical philosophy bits or deep gametheoretical and historical rationales for espoused philosophies are even remotely alluded to in the movie aside from brief. How important is the technical description in chapter 7 of starship troopers by robert a. The original titleand im not making this upwas bug hunt at outpost nine. Casper van dien and ed neumeier talk starship troopers and robocop. His future history series, incorporating both short stories and novels, was first mapped out in 1941.
Upon its release in 1997, it was critically derided as being only the second part of my. The fact that it was and continues to be taken at face value speaks to the very vapidity the. I have always been surprised that people didnt realize that it was a satire. Propaganda film from the future starship troopers, now on. He hated communism and he felt the only way to stop the communists was with nuclear weapons. The movie of starship troopers had nothing in common with the book except for the title and the heros last name. Starship troopers is donald trumps perfect war movie. Nov 07, 20 starship troopers is satire, a ruthlessly funny and keenly selfaware sendup of rightwing militarism. Johnnie is not an aryan, he is filipino juan rico is his real name, and the mi is made up of people from all over the world. Real, penetrating satire sneaks up on you and causes you consider things from a new angle. In the novel starship troopers, only veterans of federal service become full citizens with the right to vote and hold public office. Heinlein wrote starship troopers at the height of the cold war in response to a group calling for the reduction of nuclear weapons. One week after the election of donald trump, paul verhoeven was at the film society of lincoln center presenting starship troopers, a 1997 film that highlighted the fascist possibilities of.
In the movie the mobile infantry is a part of the terran army with males soldiers equipped with powered armored suits that completely enclose their. He makes starship troopers intoa satire of fascist states, casting aryan, white, blonde, beautiful people in the lead roles to further his point, and it works brilliantly, but the novel itself is not an advocate of fascism to begin with. People who assert that are showing either a personal bias against the book or the author or. What is the theme of the book starship troopers by robert a. People who assert that are showing either a personal bias against the book or the author or their ignorance of the definition of the word facist. I will say that i think the movie did a poor job on presenting itself as satire and so it gets bashed for being a bastardization of the books. But what makes starship troopers such an important book is its pioneering approach to dramatizing military themes in an sf context. Heinlein takes place in the future as humanity fights against the bugs. Neumeier states that he keeps the original tone of the book, displaying a fascist society where democracy has failed thus conveying a functional world based upon a military dictatorship.
The film was meant to be a satire of a fascistmilitaristic state and as any good satire was meant to be funny. But starship troopers is more than a showcase for hightech hardware and gigantic, fleshripping insects. Critics reassess starship troopers as a misunderstood. Starship troopers, the book, is one of my alltime favorites. Todays science fiction movies must compete with action thrillers and comicbook films, which makes robert heinleins 1959 novel starship troopers. Heinlein, and the 1997 movie of the same name, are alternatively accused of promoting or lampooning fascism. Starship troopers movie attempted the same thing but the satire was so heavy that it was lost on watchers. I wasnt around at the time, but unless i miss my guess, troopers was the first sf novel in which military life was depicted in a manner believable to readers who had actually served. The science fiction novel starship troopers 1959 by robert a.
Upon its release in 1997, it was critically derided as being only the second part of my description. Macaulay culkin on the brilliant satire of starship troopers. The book of starship troopers was inspiring and phenomenally good. Still from starship troopers, courtesy of tristar pictures the only good bug is a dead bug. The complex, seductive satire of starship troopers little white lies. Starship troopers is a satire of war films, with the fascist rhetoric cranked up to 11. In the movie the mobile infantry is a part of the terran army with males soldiers equipped with powered armored suits that completely enclose their bodies giving them high strength, mobility and endurance. It is written is a first person narrative from a young recruit johnny rico. The sole source of information, the federal network, uses as its logo a featureless golden eagle in front of a featureless circling glob.
Faithful in its depiction of the earnest jingoism of heinleins source novel, in recent years the film has been lauded by some commentators as a derisive caricature of rightwing militarism. From what i know, the film is virtually nothing like the book. How is the government in starship troopers fascist. How the satire in starship troopers works io9 gizmodo. Starship troopers is a film about the future, starring casper van dien as johnny rico, dina meyer as dizzy flores. Starship troopers is een boek uit 1959 van robert heinlein dat een zekere cultstatus heeft. Starship troopers is satire, a ruthlessly funny and keenly selfaware sendup of rightwing militarism. Of course, given that, none of the books many moralpolitical philosophy bits or deep gametheoretical and historical rationales for espoused philosophies are even remotely alluded to in the movie aside from brief. Todays science fiction movies must compete with action thrillers and comic book films, which makes robert heinleins 1959 novel starship troopers seem like a natural. I read the book ages before the movie came out, i didnt think it was a satire then and i dont think it is now. And if you have concerns, you could read it with them, or encourage them to come to you to ask about any of the more adult themes or to understand the satire. The government in the book starship troopers is not at all facist.
Recruitment commercials feature soldiers letting children play with assault rifles. Sep 14, 2016 the government in the book starship troopers is not at all facist. Starship troopers is a military science fiction novel by american writer robert a. Starship troopers is told in a narrative format that uses various flashback sequences to help flesh out the narrator and protagonist johnny rico. Is starship troopers a critiquesatire of star treks world and worldview or a ripoff, in particular of the devil in the dark episode, with some aliens, top gun, and an officer and a gentleman tossed into the mix. Starship troopers was clearly influential in leading.
I wasnt around at the time, but unless i miss my guess, troopers was the first sf novel in which military life was depicted in a. In the starship troopers movie, what remains of robert a. In 1985, more than a decade before starship troopers, j. As was the case with many of heinleins books, starship troopers was completed in a few weeks. Why everyone gets robocop but nobody gets starship troopers. Starship troopers project gutenberg selfpublishing. It wasnt until similarities to the novel were pointed out that names and events were tweaked and the book rights were licensed. Paul verhoevens starship troopers, adapted from a heinleins controversial 1959 novel, bears little resemblance to. Nov 08, 2017 still from starship troopers, courtesy of tristar pictures the only good bug is a dead bug. Your best route is almost certainly the one you have taken read the book yourself and decide whether you are happy with your child reading it. Then again, starship troopers isnt a satire about any specific war, its a brilliant dissection of how all wars workhow theyre packaged and sold via propaganda, how the enemy is in this case, literally dehumanized, how young people are sent eagerly to sacrifice on the front lines. Mar 18, 2017 is starship troopers a critiquesatire of star treks world and worldview or a ripoff, in particular of the devil in the dark episode, with some aliens, top gun, and an officer and a gentleman tossed into the mix. Paul verhoevens 1997 film, while a masterpiece in its own right, misses much of the nuance of the original novel.
Differences between starship troopers book vs movie page 1. Starship troopers does not so much skewer militarism as it depicts it and adds the occasional raised eyebrow. Dec 12, 2015 the book of starship troopers was inspiring and phenomenally good. Was verhoevens starship troopers intended to be a satire on war. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading starship troopers. Ricos journey is heinleins way of pushing his own ideas about military service, the failures of democracy and his burgeoning philosophical anarchism. Starship troopers kindle edition by heinlein, robert a download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Is starship troopers, a fascist satire, coming true.
719 98 1485 760 455 941 839 1449 894 74 1335 293 36 655 1192 1218 1289 557 1286 1111 184 1307 416 588 53 1401 1226 169 1076 167 1088 3 491 297 1453 1023 3 597 808 204 1162 1470